diff --git a/docs/workflow/develop-workflow-record.md b/docs/workflow/develop-workflow-record.md index 2b53e2b..acebc55 100644 --- a/docs/workflow/develop-workflow-record.md +++ b/docs/workflow/develop-workflow-record.md @@ -3,8 +3,8 @@ ## Status - Status: active -- Current phase: exceptional focused remediation -- Next safe action: verify lock pathname identity before cleanup, add the replacement-lock regression test, then reverify and obtain fresh independent review. +- Current phase: exceptional remediation review +- Next safe action: commit this final review brief, prove its metadata-only scope, and launch fresh independent reviewers. ## Request and scope @@ -154,12 +154,16 @@ Before integration, abandon only by preserving evidence and obtaining cleanup ap ## Review -- Review fixed point: base `b4373113a404bb523bef306a66fb8a22fc706223`, product HEAD `b4e71b47db4af3455ab665050f51b96c0bed3959`. +- Review fixed point: base `b4373113a404bb523bef306a66fb8a22fc706223`, product HEAD `52576c755666f95a40907b0500f095c6d314c346`. - Specification sources: this record and the accepted skill-led workflow plan. - Mutators: parent agent, `checkpoint-implementer`, and `reviewer-profile-implementer`; the worker names identify ambiguous runs because stable child IDs were unavailable. - Product status: clean at pin time. -- Product tree: `1efcde6ccbd81063a44c46a3b75b34d50d3af4b0`. +- Product tree: `e60ba10af999203234edaeea29fc06f93e7b0a39`. - Commit list: + - 52576c755666f95a40907b0500f095c6d314c346 fix(skills): preserve replaced checkpoint locks + - 444483ade6be2591bd163f663af54cf343fb58b8 docs: approve focused lock remediation + - ebab671969afbf0ad7fb22b7a81d1bfa0241a278 docs: record post-rebase review finding + - b556bcf147c9a94b1a172634d2ca8a263f2fe737 docs: pin post-rebase develop workflow review - b4e71b47db4af3455ab665050f51b96c0bed3959 docs: record dirty source resolution - 1782d1a0c6afabcdf590c8a47a9ff848a10d3481 docs: record final develop workflow approval - a241fb05aefa930d5fef543b24cf162e3d998985 docs: pin final develop workflow review @@ -178,8 +182,8 @@ Before integration, abandon only by preserving evidence and obtaining cleanup ap - 6389d22f1505669587d0809c1ed59a040630d3d9 docs: checkpoint develop workflow plan approval - fbf1a52b647d3aed7f9b275097384144af5a0eef docs: record develop workflow implementation plan - 06e631504cb7df74ded1f4a4651fcf00c86e6ed4 docs: initialize develop workflow record -- Exact diff command: `git diff --binary --full-index --find-renames b4373113a404bb523bef306a66fb8a22fc706223...b4e71b47db4af3455ab665050f51b96c0bed3959 --`. -- Exact diff SHA-256: `3fd063ad1a4591e776ef2a29c26f31482bbcb5329a6541126fd991c72a0d247f`. +- Exact diff command: `git diff --binary --full-index --find-renames b4373113a404bb523bef306a66fb8a22fc706223...52576c755666f95a40907b0500f095c6d314c346 --`. +- Exact diff SHA-256: `8da3680c6f0a9065ed6f509ba431253d91d89190ce048b4ece2d05e1b2755be0`. - Cycle 1 standards reviewer: `develop-workflow-standards-review` / `precedent-locator` / child `b374d808` / session `01a06cc9-0b63-7d1d-ab7d-47c8286ac5f1`; digest confirmed; CHANGES REQUESTED. - Cycle 1 specification reviewer: `develop-workflow-spec-review` / `claim-verifier` / child `8e5f72cd` / session `01a06cc9-4d3f-7a6d-a6ab-37a383956368`; digest confirmed; CHANGES REQUESTED. - Before/after reviewer evidence: both reported unchanged branch, HEAD, status, tree, paths, metadata-only delta, product tree, and digest; repository remains clean. @@ -193,7 +197,10 @@ Before integration, abandon only by preserving evidence and obtaining cleanup ap - Cycle 3 before/after evidence: both reviewers reported matching product tree/digest, metadata-only delta, and clean unchanged state. Both review axes approved the pre-rebase product fingerprint. - Post-rebase review standards reviewer: `develop-workflow-post-rebase-standards` / `precedent-locator` / child `b476565e` / session `01a06ce4-3bf5-707e-900f-34509a9801b4`; digest confirmed; APPROVE with no findings. - Post-rebase review specification reviewer: display `:1`, profile/child unavailable, session `01a06ce5-2764-7596-96a7-50a52309b921`; digest confirmed; CHANGES REQUESTED. -- Accepted medium finding: checkpoint cleanup unconditionally unlinks the lock pathname. If the invocation-owned lock is removed and replaced while its original handle remains open, cleanup can delete another invocation’s lock. This violates the approved requirement to clean up only files and locks owned by the current invocation. +- Accepted medium finding: checkpoint cleanup unconditionally unlinked the lock pathname. If the invocation-owned lock was removed and replaced while its original handle remained open, cleanup could delete another invocation’s lock. +- Exceptional remediation: capture the acquired lock inode/device identity and unlink the lock pathname only when its current identity still matches; regression test replaces the lock during active cleanup and proves the replacement remains. +- Exceptional remediation standards reviewer: pending fresh identity and digest confirmation. +- Exceptional remediation specification reviewer: pending fresh identity and digest confirmation. - This review-brief checkpoint is necessarily a metadata-only commit after the pinned product HEAD because a record cannot contain the digest of bytes that include its own digest. Prove it touches only this record. ## Integration and rollback @@ -223,4 +230,6 @@ Rebase the feature branch onto the latest remote/local `main` when available, re - Post-rebase review outcome: standards approved; specification requested a focused lock-ownership fix. Both reviewers reported unchanged clean Git state. - Escalation decision: after two earlier remediation cycles, the user explicitly authorized one exceptional focused remediation cycle for this lock-ownership finding. - Approved remediation scope: capture the acquired lock identity, unlink only when the pathname still resolves to that identity, and add a regression test that replaces the pathname during an active checkpoint. -- Next safe action: commit this gate decision before the parent-owned code mutation. +- Remediation result: implemented the approved scope at `52576c755666f95a40907b0500f095c6d314c346`; focused tests now pass 14/14, link tests pass 8/8, `bun run typecheck` exits 0, and `bun run test` exits 0. +- Final review fingerprint: tree `e60ba10af999203234edaeea29fc06f93e7b0a39`, digest `8da3680c6f0a9065ed6f509ba431253d91d89190ce048b4ece2d05e1b2755be0`. +- Next safe action: commit this metadata-only brief and obtain fresh independent approval.