From 5ddd98bf5f76c6b1f3212e0f80be823ed7abe683 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: JB Date: Mon, 21 Sep 2026 13:58:11 -0400 Subject: [PATCH] docs: close reviewed fast-browser performance workflow --- docs/plans/fast-browser-performance.md | 31 +++++++++++++++++--------- 1 file changed, 21 insertions(+), 10 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/plans/fast-browser-performance.md b/docs/plans/fast-browser-performance.md index db87160..20d1ece 100644 --- a/docs/plans/fast-browser-performance.md +++ b/docs/plans/fast-browser-performance.md @@ -2,9 +2,9 @@ ## Status -- Status: active -- Current phase: final verified product ready for independent review. -- Next safe action: pin the clean committed diff, run independent standards/specification reviews, then integrate only through the approved safe source-checkout gate. +- Status: complete +- Current phase: verified, independently approved product fast-forwarded to local main. +- Next safe action: after this record-only closure commit, run final sanity/reachability checks, remove the owned clean worktree/branch, and restore the unrelated file's Git visibility. Final housekeeping evidence is written to `/tmp/pi-present/fast-browser-performance-cleanup.json`. ## Request and scope @@ -100,15 +100,25 @@ Each mutating assignment has a 15-minute deadline. B and C are separate assignme ## Review -Review fixed point: final verified product commits against the fetched source base. Specification is the approved committed record. Standards sources are repository/global AGENTS.md plus fast-browser contracts. - -Two new read-only Git-capable `claim-verifier` sessions independently review standards and specification. All authors, parent, and worker identities are excluded. Parent pins base, product HEAD, clean status, tree, commit list and SHA-256 of `git diff --binary --full-index --find-renames ... --`. Reviewers reproduce the digest. Accepted fixes go back to an implementer, followed by verification and fresh independent review. +- Review base: `773c628512fdfdf5a139ae1b27833bea97d74255`; product HEAD: `54303e0b5d8d99dbd3556a7a97453157e7ed09fd`; product tree: `08de591daedd2b32a64d3e054097d9cdd040089d`. +- Exact command: `git diff --binary --full-index --find-renames 773c628512fdfdf5a139ae1b27833bea97d74255...54303e0b5d8d99dbd3556a7a97453157e7ed09fd --`. +- Diff SHA-256: `717829461c80874a99ca24f5ef0d85094e237b1b3238ef40c827672f5b0b670e`. +- Commit list, newest first: 54303e0, 2dc359c, fe643e2, 12a6bb6, 6a725c1, f2e42f5, acd57ae, e10a957, 574e083, 4360f01, c0c18a5, 3c321b3, a79418e, 05793fe, 6fba628. Reproduce with `git log --oneline ..` using the pinned full IDs above. +- Excluded mutators: parent and all worker sessions (`browser-hotpath`, `runtime-hotpath`, `performance-benchmark`). Stable worker session IDs were not exposed, so the worker profile was excluded. +- Standards reviewer: `performance-standards-review`, read-only claim-verifier, session `01a0c515-7d1a-7680-9e5b-d16aa4202b6b`. Confirmed exact digest and APPROVED with zero findings. +- Specification reviewer: `performance-specification-review`, independent read-only claim-verifier; stable session ID not exposed. Confirmed exact digest and APPROVED with zero findings. +- Both reviewers and parent confirmed unchanged clean HEAD/tree/status before and after review. No remediation cycle was required. Specifications were this approved record and development contracts; standards were repository/global AGENTS.md and established fast-browser patterns. +- Full brief and separate axis results are retained at `/tmp/pi-present/fast-browser-performance-review-brief.md` and `/tmp/pi-present/fast-browser-performance-review-results.md`. Closure changes only this record, outside the approved product fingerprint. ## Integration and rollback -Commit checked slices locally, fetch source again and rebase only if needed, reverify any changed tree, then review. Fast-forward integration only. Existing untracked source material stays untouched; if the source checkout is still dirty, pause integration rather than moving or deleting it. Approval of omission does not authorize removing the unrelated file. +Source was fetched again and remained at the pinned base; no rebase was needed. Both review approvals and the exact digest were rechecked before `git merge --ff-only feature/fast-browser-performance`, which succeeded on local main. Source main now contains the exact reviewed product. -After safe integration, make one record-only closure commit, prove reachability, and remove only the clean owned worktree/branch. No push or publish. Rollback is a normal revert of focused optimization commits; retain benchmark tooling if useful. If batching fails acceptance, drop only its uncommitted owned changes through a reviewed non-destructive patch, preserving other slices and benchmark evidence. +The user explicitly approved `temporary_local_exclude` through ask_user for the unrelated untracked `docs/local-decision-model-feasibility.md`: temporarily exclude that exact path, require a clean source checkout, fast-forward, close and clean up, then restore its original untracked visibility. No contents or tracked state may change. The initial and post-fast-forward SHA-256 are both `5bb4fbf4c77742d41a230d25d87c4e4fd607a5bd38851bf61c7eaf022ebfd86c`. Approval evidence is `/tmp/pi-present/fast-browser-integration-approval.md`. + +Product commit is the pinned HEAD above. The next commit touching only this record is the metadata-only closure commit; its ID is discoverable with `git log -1 -- docs/plans/fast-browser-performance.md`. Final sanity checks prove product/closure reachability and clean owned worktree state before normal `git worktree remove` and `git branch -d`. The final cleanup evidence file records actual results after this commit, including restored visibility and unchanged document hash. Only the explicitly owned worktree/branch and temporary local exclude entries are removed. No push, publication, installed-package change or Pi reload occurred. + +Rollback is a normal revert of focused optimization commits, retaining benchmark tooling if useful. ## Checkpoints and blockers @@ -127,5 +137,6 @@ After safe integration, make one record-only closure commit, prove reachability, - Browser-hotpath correction assignment: 15 minutes, same Python worker/test paths; before HEAD 12a6bb6, only owned red tests dirty plus parent doc. Implement single-dispatch close followed by bounded inventory reads under existing ACTION_TIMEOUT_SECONDS. Replace pinned helper's 300ms readiness sleep with <=25ms bounded monotonic polling for the exact same document.readyState == complete predicate and existing timeout, retaining error propagation. Add readiness regression tests before the fix. This changes private polling cadence, not API, security posture, postconditions or budgets. Before patch `/tmp/pi-present/performance-close-red.patch`. - Corrected close/readiness worker committed 2dc359c; parent inspected patch `/tmp/pi-present/performance-readiness-close-fix.patch` and reran 61 Python tests. Final report `/tmp/fast-browser-performance-20-pairs-final.json` passed all 46 attempts; hash and exact environment/commands are in performance documentation. - Final verification background task bg_vjl_mubjba9s_12 exited 0 after typecheck, complete repository suite, pinned Python suite, real Chromium runtime test, scenario preflight and diff check. No failures; opt-in general-profile test remains skipped in the default suite, while the development live gate was explicitly run. -- Source fetched again: origin/main still 773c628512fdfdf5a139ae1b27833bea97d74255, no rebase needed. Source checkout still has only the unrelated untracked feasibility document; final integration requires a bounded decision or a clean checkout. -- Next safe action: commit final documentation, pin review bytes, launch independent read-only reviewers. Preserve every failed result. +- Both independent reviewers approved the pinned product with zero findings. Source main was clean under the user-approved temporary exact-file exclusion, fast-forward integration succeeded, and the unrelated document hash remained unchanged. +- No unresolved product blockers. Failed earlier measurements remain retained and documented. +- Next safe action: finalize this record-only closure commit and execute the stated post-commit sanity, reachability, cleanup and visibility-restoration checks.